– Spring 2027, In Person.
Our subjectivity is as intimately bound up with what we are as humans as it is elusive and resistant to our efforts to theorize about it. So what is subjectivity? The philosopher René Descartes has provided one of the most influential answers to this question: to be a subject is to be a thinking thing, a substance capable of consciousness and reasoning. In so doing, he established the basic conceptual grammar and vocabulary for subsequent philosophy of subjectivity, shaping the space of possible argument and counterargument. This course explores how one particular line of development of this Cartesian tradition – originating with Descartes and culminating in the thought of the 20th century phenomenologist, Edmund Husserl – takes up, develops, critiques and transcends Descartes’ starting point.
We will explore how the Husserlian philosophy of subjectivity leaves us with a paradoxical picture of the subject as both 1) a part of the world, insofar as it is an embodied subject shaped by its community belonging and historical tradition, and 2) apart from the world, insofar as it is a transcendental subject that is a general condition for the possible intelligibility of the world. We will also explore how Husserl’s rethinking of the problem of explaining the relation between subjectivity and the world is markedly different from the so-called “hard problem of consciousness” as it is understood in Analytic philosophy of mind following David Chalmers and Thomas Nagel. Aside from introducing students to the intellectual history of the Cartesian tradition of philosophizing about subjectivity, the course provides a general introduction to the phenomenological method as conceived by Husserl and developed by later thinkers.
Subjectivity has given rise to some of the most intractable conceptual muddles in the history of philosophy. Our goal will be to explore how the phenomenological method, by disclosing the essential structures of subjectivity, provides us with some of the conceptual, descriptive and argumentative tools to approach these muddles. The result of our philosophical inquiry will be a deepened capacity to peel away the veneer of familiarity surrounding our subjectivity so that we can disclose it for the inexhaustible source of wonder that it is.